5 Comments
User's avatar
Late Blooming's avatar

This is so cynical. Better plan: be who you are, and sell your vision. Don’t fucking back down from a fight! People aren’t stupid, generally.

Andrew C White's avatar

Thank you. I've been thinking about writing a post similar to this. Glad to see it out there and with data to back up the point.

When I first got into politics in a Republican area of upstate NY I was told not to say I was a Democrat, not to put it on signs or literature. I strongly disagreed. Running away from the party is weak and self-defeating. It might take multiple cycles but you do the work, do the organizing, build the trust, and you win in unlikely seeming places.

SAS's avatar

In red Montana, the Independent brand gained traction because the Democrats did not have a well known or widely supported Senatorial candidate, and disillusioned election whisperers like former Senator Jon Tester encouraged an ill-defined “third way.”

The zeitgeist changed between Seth Bodnar’s filing as an Independent and the midterms.

First, it was unclear what separated him from the Dems beyond vague talking points. And by midterms people were so thoroughly disenchanted by Trump and his ilk that a blue wave has suddenly become viable. Who knew?

To be fair, whether Bodnar could have won running as Dem is questionable. Despite his military background, Bodnar is a former college president in the “liberal hell hole” of Missoula.

But in the end, Bodnar’s and his supporters’ strategy proved to be too clever by half. Apparently the other Independents’ strategy too.

SavvyGranny's avatar

This COMPLETELY ignores the impact BLACK voters, particularly black women, have on the Democratic party. It's almost as if we don't matter at all! Certain people in this society better get used to the fact that rich white men are about to become obsolete (at least i hope so).

David Muccigrosso's avatar

The biggest problem with this is that no matter what, Bankhead should have gone along with the party once the decision was made.

If we’re going to hold the line against foolishness like Stevens in Michigan, then the same principle has to apply in Montana.

The reality is, Bankhead rose through the ranks in a state party that wasn’t doing its job — otherwise there’d have already been more Democrats. These state parties aren’t just innocent little wallflowers in a vacuum; in states where they’ve resigned to being the out-party, a lot of crappy dynamics end up ruling and they develop an unacceptable sense of entitlement over the fiefdoms that the other side grants them. We shouldn’t coddle or baby these state parties, we should impose discipline, and a national party that can’t do that has a larger problem than merely being unpopular in that state.